Skip to content
The Wealth Blog

NPS

NPS vs APY: Which Pension Scheme Should You Choose?

NPS vs APY compared for 2027: guaranteed Rs 1,000–5,000 pension vs market-linked growth, the taxpayer bar, contribution charts, exit rules and who should hold which.

By Om PatelPublished 9 Jul 2026Last reviewed 1 Nov 20269 min readPart of NPS: every rule, comparison and how-to
Static-verified · 1 Nov 2026
Hand-drawn cover illustration of NPS versus Atal Pension Yojana guide — The Wealth Blog
Hand-drawn cover illustration of NPS versus Atal Pension Yojana guide — The Wealth Blog

If you are trying to pick between NPS (National Pension System) and APY (Atal Pension Yojana), here is the short version: APY gives you a guaranteed pension of Rs 1,000 to Rs 5,000 per month, but only if you do not pay income tax and are under 40. NPS gives you market-linked returns with tax benefits across three sections, but no guaranteed payout. Quick decision: do not pay income tax and under 40? Start with APY, add NPS later. Pay income tax? Go straight to NPS. Want both? That works too. Now the why.

Two friends, same city, same age, completely different retirement problems. Ravi delivers food in Pune, earning Rs 18,000 a month. He does not file income tax returns. His question is dead simple: will I have enough when I am 60? Sneha codes at a Pune IT firm and takes home Rs 65,000. She pays income tax and wants her retirement money to beat inflation. Both are staring at the same two government schemes — but the right pick for each is completely different.

Key takeaways

  1. APY guarantees Rs 1,000–5,000 a month for life after 60 but is open only to non-taxpayers aged 18–40 (new accounts barred for income-tax payers since October 1, 2022).
  2. NPS is open to everyone aged 18–70, invests in equity plus debt, and offers tax benefits under three sections — but guarantees nothing.
  3. Starting APY at 18 costs Rs 210 a month for the Rs 5,000 pension; starting at 40 costs Rs 1,454 for the same payout.
  4. Since October 2025, NPS non-government subscribers can go up to 100% equity under the Multiple Scheme Framework, and at exit keep up to 80% as lump sum with 20% annuity.
  5. APY voluntary exit before 60 refunds only your own contributions plus net accrued income — the government co-contribution and its earnings are forfeited.
  6. APY's guaranteed Rs 5,000 will feel like roughly Rs 775 after 30 years at 6% inflation; NPS equity exposure is the inflation hedge.
  7. If you are eligible for both, the combo works: APY as the guaranteed floor, NPS as the growth engine.

What Is Atal Pension Yojana (APY)?

APY launched on May 9, 2015. The pitch: you put in a fixed amount every month, and the government guarantees a pension of Rs 1,000 to Rs 5,000 per month after age 60. Contribute for at least 20 years, get the fixed payout for life. The government backs the guarantee.

How Much Do You Actually Pay?

5 of 5 rows

Comparison table
Entry ageFor Rs 1,000/monthFor Rs 3,000/monthFor Rs 5,000/month
18 yearsRs 42Rs 126Rs 210
25 yearsRs 76Rs 226Rs 376
30 yearsRs 116Rs 347Rs 577
35 yearsRs 181Rs 543Rs 902
40 yearsRs 291Rs 873Rs 1,454

Your monthly contribution depends on your entry age and the pension tier:

Source: PFRDA APY contribution chart (as circulated by APY-enrolled banks). The younger you start, the less you pay — compounding works in your favour here.

Where Does Your Money Go?

APY invests 100% in debt — roughly 55–65% in Government Securities and the rest in other debt instruments. No equity at all. Steady, but low. Source: PFRDA investment guidelines for APY.

What Is National Pension System (NPS)?

NPS started on January 1, 2004 for government employees and opened to all citizens in 2009. Your money goes into a mix of equity, corporate bonds and government securities; returns depend on the market. You can join until age 70 and stay invested until 85. Source: PFRDA Exit Regulations, December 2025 amendment.

  • From October 1, 2025, non-government subscribers can put 100% of contributions into equity under the Multiple Scheme Framework (MSF) — earlier, equity was capped at 75%. Source: PFRDA MSF circular, effective 1 Oct 2025.
  • At exit you keep up to 80% as lump sum, with only 20% needed for an annuity (down from 40%). Source: PFRDA (Exits and Withdrawals) Amendment Regulations, December 2025.

NPS Fund Performance (5-Year Returns, as of December 2025)

NPS Tax Benefits Under Section 80CCD

  • 80CCD(1): deduction up to 10% of salary (salaried) or 20% of gross total income (self-employed), within the 80C ceiling — old regime.
  • 80CCD(1B): an extra Rs 50,000, NPS-exclusive — old regime.
  • 80CCD(2): employer contributions deductible up to 14% of salary under the new regime (all employees since FY 2024-25) — works in both regimes.

NPS vs APY: Head-to-Head

10 of 10 rows

Comparison table
FactorAPYNPS
EligibilityAge 18–40, non-taxpayers only (new accounts)Age 18–70, everyone
Guaranteed pensionYes — Rs 1,000 to 5,000/monthNo — market-linked
Where money goes100% government debtEquity up to 100% (MSF) + bonds + G-Secs
RiskVery lowMedium to high
Exit age6060, deferrable to 75–85
What you get at exitMonthly pension for lifeUp to 80% lump sum + 20% annuity
Tax on pensionTaxable at slabTaxable at slab
Change contributions?Fixed tiersAnytime, up or down
Fund choiceNone10+ pension fund managers
Beats inflation?UnlikelyLikely, with equity exposure

Inflation: The Math Most People Skip

Today, Rs 5,000 covers a family of four's groceries for 8–10 days. At 6% inflation — a common planning assumption — that same Rs 5,000 in 2058 buys what roughly Rs 775 buys today. Barely a day or two of groceries.

APY's guaranteed Rs 5,000 sounds fine now and will feel thin in 30 years. NPS equity exposure is riskier short-term but has historically beaten inflation — Indian equity has delivered 12–15% long-run returns against 6% inflation. That is the whole trade: certainty vs purchasing power.

Premature Exit Rules

APY: What Happens If You Exit Early

If you voluntarily exit APY before 60, you get back only your own contributions plus the net actual accrued income on them. The government co-contribution and the income earned on it are forfeited, and you do not receive the guaranteed-pension benefit at all — it is a refund, not a pension. On the subscriber's death, the full corpus goes to the nominee. Source: PFRDA/CRA circular on processing premature APY exit requests; APY scheme FAQ (jansuraksha.gov.in).

NPS Premature Exit (December 2025 Rules)

  • The old 5-year lock-in for All Citizen subscribers was removed entirely.
  • Vesting period: 15 years or age 60, whichever comes first, to qualify for a normal exit.
  • Premature exit: up to 20% lump sum, at least 80% into annuity.
  • Small corpus: Rs 5 lakh or less at premature exit means 100% cash, no annuity (raised from Rs 2.5 lakh).
  • At 60: up to 80% lump sum, 20% annuity — but only the first 60% of the corpus is tax-free under Section 10(12A).
  • Partial withdrawals: up to 25% of your own contributions after 3 years, for medical treatment, education, marriage or a first house.

Source: PFRDA (Exits and Withdrawals) Amendment Regulations, December 2025.

Who Should Pick What, By Age and Income

Age 25–30

Age 30–40

Age 40+

The Combo Strategy: APY + NPS Together

If you are eligible for both, use both: APY as the guaranteed floor, NPS as the upside.

Ravi's plan (delivery executive, Rs 18,000/month, non-taxpayer): APY at Rs 116/month for a Rs 1,000 guaranteed pension, plus a Rs 2,000 equity SIP. Total outgo Rs 2,116.

Sneha's plan (software engineer, Rs 65,000/month, taxpayer): Rs 5,000/month into NPS with 75%+ equity (100% available via MSF), harvesting the 80CCD deductions where her regime allows.

Worked Examples

How big a corpus do you need? Monthly expenses of Rs 30,000 (Rs 3.6 lakh a year) x 25 — the common rule of thumb at a 4% withdrawal rate — gives a target of about Rs 90 lakh.

Rs 2,000/month SIP over 30 years at 12% grows to roughly Rs 70 lakh. Compounding is slow at first, then accelerates.

Risks and Limits, Straight Up

Five Things You Can Do This Week

1. Figure out if you pay income tax. If yes, APY is off the table for new accounts. Go NPS.

1. Calculate your retirement number: annual expenses x 25. Write it down.

1. Start with what you can afford. Rs 500/month is fine; raise it 10% a year. The habit beats the amount.

1. Pick your equity split. Conservative 25%, moderate 50%, aggressive up to 100% via MSF.

1. Set up auto-debit for whichever scheme you choose. Missed contributions dent both compounding and, in APY's case, attract overdue charges.

The Short Version

Frequently asked questions

NPS vs APY: which is better in 2027?

If you pay income tax, APY is closed to you for new accounts (since October 2022), so NPS is the choice. If you are a non-taxpayer under 40, APY's guaranteed pension makes a solid floor and NPS can be added later for growth.

Can I open both NPS and APY at the same time?

Yes. If you are eligible for APY (non-taxpayer, aged 18–40), you can hold both — APY for a guaranteed minimum pension and NPS for market-linked growth and tax benefits.

What is the APY contribution for a Rs 5,000 pension at age 30?

Rs 577 a month if you start at 30. For the Rs 1,000 tier it is Rs 116, and for Rs 3,000 it is Rs 347. The younger you start, the lower the monthly outgo.

What happens to APY if I become a taxpayer later?

Nothing changes for existing accounts. The October 2022 rule only blocks new account openings by income-tax payers — if you already hold APY, you can keep contributing until 60.

Is NPS tax-free at maturity?

Partly. Up to 60% of the corpus withdrawn at exit is tax-free under Section 10(12A). PFRDA allows non-government subscribers up to 80% as lump sum, but the extra 20% is taxable at slab rates, and annuity income is taxable when received.

About the author

Om Patel is an investor, blogger and entrepreneur. Every guide is educational, not personalised advice; rates and rules are cited to official sources and reviewed with a visible date.

Educational content, not personalised advice. Rates change — verify on the bank's site before opening an account. How we make money

Related guides